John Heaton (jheaton) wrote,
John Heaton

At long last, the Best Picture nominees

So, about those best picture nominees. I'll taken them in the order in which I saw them.

Michael Clayton is what I like to call "a really good example of the kind of thing that it is." What I mean by that is that it's about as good a genre film as you can make. It has a tight script and excellent performances from George Clooney, Tom Wilkinson, and especially Tilda Swinton. I don't feel it brought anything new or revolutionary to the genre, but I really liked it. I wouldn't vote for it though.

No Country For Old Men is, as I've said before, a movie I thought was really good but didn't like very much. Good performances, well written, beautiful cinematography, but it never came together for me. That's a problem with being a plot whore; when you run across a movie that doesn't have a satisfying conclusion, like this one, it tends to leave you a little cold. I wouldn't vote for it, but I won't be disappointed if (when?) it wins.

Atonement was a great movie. It wasn't perfect; I think the performances were the weakest of the five best picture nominees (with the exception of Saoirse Ronan). But aside from that, I thought this was just about perfect. Well written, ambitiously directed and photographed -- loved that Dunkirk tracking shot! -- tremendously moving, and the best score I've heard in a long time. I loved the way Dario Marianelli incorporated various sound effects into the music. I would like to see Atonement win Best Picture, but I'll be heartbroken if it doesn't win Best Score. (And by the way, it's SEER-shuh.)

Juno was an interesting film. The dialogue is snappy enough and the acting strong enough that I didn't notice until several days later how formulaic it is. The arc of Juno and Paulie's relationship is straight out of a hundred romantic comedies and romance novels. Only the pregnancy angle saves it from utter conventionality. But you know, maybe it's just because I'm a sucker for romantic comedies, but it worked for me. I wouldn't have nominated it for Best Picture, but Best Original Screenplay? Sure, if only because of that Woody Allen joke.

There Will Be Blood was better than I expected, but maybe that's just because I had low expectations going into it. A great performance by Daniel Day-Lewis, to be sure, but I really didn't like the score. Not as bad as that of The Hours, but like that one I think the score made the picture worse.

In the final analysis, I'd rank them in this order:
  1. Atonement
  2. Michael Clayton
  3. Juno
  4. There Will Be Blood
  5. No Country For Old Men
I think No Country will win, but truth be told, I wouldn't be unhappy to see any of these walk away with the top prize. It's a solid class of nominees.

  • My tweets

    Fri, 13:55: Or just not build one in the first place. Hey, did you know Madison, Wisconsin didn't have a public pool until 2006? Fun fact.…

  • My tweets

    Thu, 12:20: Very much so, and this band specifically. Hoping against hope they'll schedule a few dates before the end of the year so I can…

  • My tweets

    Wed, 21:40: Everyone thinks it's bonkers to have Avatar included here but has anyone considered the possibility he used the wrong logo…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.